“Why These Christian Podcasts Faded: Too Controversial or Out of Season?”

Revised Blog Post: “Why These Christian Podcasts Faded: Too Controversial or Out of Season?”

Bad Christian Podcast

Hello, ChristianPodcast.com™ family!

In 2019, we envisioned a Christian podcast directory, a place to explore faith-based media that inspires, challenges, and sometimes stirs debate. Today, we’re looking at five Christian podcasts that pushed boundaries, with most no longer active. Were they too controversial, or was their season simply complete?

Join us as we explore these stories and invite your thoughts in the comments—what stands out to you? (¡Y para nuestra comunidad hispanohablante, compartan sus reflexiones en los comentarios: ¿qué les impactó?) P.S. Stay tuned for a future post on atheist podcasts like Atheist Nomads—how will they challenge or inform our faith?

1. The Bad Christian Podcast (2014–2020, Inactive)

Hosted by Matt Carter, Toby Morrell, and Joey Svendsen of the band Emery, The Bad Christian Podcast offered candid discussions on faith, doubt, and church culture. Episodes like “Porn, Masturbation, and the Church” tackled sensitive topics with raw honesty, sparking controversy among some listeners. By 2020, the podcast ended—perhaps its bold approach was too divisive, or its time had passed.

2. The Liturgists Podcast (2014–2020, Inactive)

Michael Gungor and Science Mike explored progressive Christianity through The Liturgists, addressing deconstruction and inclusivity. Episodes like “Christian Atheism” or “God Our Mother” challenged traditional views, drawing criticism from conservative circles. The podcast ceased in 2020—did its ideas go too far, or was a new chapter unfolding?

3. The Bible for Normal People (2017–Present, Active)

Pete Enns and Jared Byas dive into biblical scholarship, questioning literal interpretations in episodes like “Did the Exodus Really Happen?” Its academic approach continues to spark discussion, appealing to curious minds while unsettling some traditionalists. Perhaps its staying power reflects a balance of challenge and faith.

4. Theology in the Raw (2013–Present, Active)

Preston Sprinkle hosts Theology in the Raw, tackling complex issues like sexuality and politics with diverse guests. Episodes exploring affirming theology have stirred debate, yet the podcast remains active. Its commitment to honest dialogue may be why it endures.

5. Drunk Bible Study (2016–2020, Inactive)

Erin Camp and Katie Anderson brought a lighthearted approach to scripture, discussing verses over wine. Their casual, sometimes humorous style raised eyebrows, with some calling it disrespectful. By 2020, the podcast concluded—perhaps its tone clashed with expectations, or its season ended.

A Season for Everything

Three of these podcasts—The Bad Christian Podcast, The Liturgists, and Drunk Bible Study—are no longer active. Were they too controversial for Christian audiences, or did their purpose run its course? Ecclesiastes 3:1 reminds us, “There is a time for everything, and a season for every activity under the heavens.” At ChristianPodcast.com™, we’re committed to sharing stories that deepen faith and spark reflection, trusting God’s plan is always at work.

What are your thoughts—why did these podcasts fade, and what can we learn from them? Share in the comments below! (¿Qué opinan: por qué terminaron estos podcasts y qué podemos aprender? ¡Compartan en los comentarios!)

Stay Connected

We’re building a faith-based media hub for the 21st century, and you’re part of it! Explore Christian Podcast™ con Beto y Mili for authentic conversations, and keep an eye out for more content that inspires and challenges. Follow us on X (@ChristianPodcast) to suggest podcasts for our Community Spotlight—perhaps atheist ones like Atheist Nomads next. Let’s keep growing in faith together—God’s story leads the way!

¡Gracias por ser parte de nuestra familia! Descubre más en inglés y español en ChristianPodcast.com™, y comparte tus ideas en los comentarios.